Short answer
On gentle slopes, mulch is often enough. As slopes get steeper, or when heavy rain is likely, erosion control blankets usually hold soil and seed better because they are anchored to the ground. Mulch can wash or blow away, especially light or large pieces. Many people use both: a blanket over the soil, with plants set through it.
What each does
Both protect bare soil from raindrop impact, slow runoff, hold moisture and shade seedlings. The difference is how well they stay put. Mulch is loose and relies on its own weight and friction. A blanket is a mat of fibre, often held with netting, pinned down with stakes or staples.
Types of blanket
- Straw blankets: straw held between biodegradable netting. A common and affordable choice for seeded slopes.
- Coconut (coir) blankets: coir fibre is long-lasting compared with straw and is often used on steeper slopes or where water flows.
- Jute netting: an open weave that holds mulch or straw in place and breaks down over time.
- Wood fibre and mixed blankets: also available.
- Blankets are sold with different lifespans, and the product label tells you the intended slope steepness and duration. Follow it.
Types of mulch
- Straw: inexpensive and good for covering seed, but it blows away on slopes unless pinned down with netting or a tackifier. Use clean, weed-free straw.
- Shredded bark or leaf mulch: interlocks better than large chips and stays put on moderate slopes.
- Wood chips: work on gentle slopes, but larger pieces can wash downhill on steeper ones.
- Compost: feeds the soil but can wash away if not held down.
- Gravel or stone: stays put better than organic mulch in some cases, but it is heavy and can slide on steep ground.
Comparison
| Blanket | Mulch | |
|---|---|---|
| Holds on steep slopes | Better (when staked) | Weaker |
| Cost | Higher | Lower |
| Labour | More careful installation | Quick to spread |
| Feeds soil | Little | Yes (organic types) |
| Good with seed | Yes | Straw works |
| Best for | Steep, seeded or flowing-water areas | Gentle slopes, planted beds |
Which to choose by slope
- Gentle slopes: mulch, such as shredded bark, is usually fine.
- Moderate slopes: mulch with netting, or a lightweight blanket.
- Steep slopes or channels where water flows: a staked blanket, and possibly coir logs at the base. For a stream, see how to stop erosion in a creek.
- Seeding grass: a straw blanket works well. See grasses that prevent soil erosion.
- Established plant beds: mulch, with the plants doing the long-term work. See ground cover vs mulch for how the two compare in beds.
Installing a blanket
- Grade the slope smooth and remove stones and clumps.
- Seed or plant first, where the product allows.
- Roll the blanket down the slope, in contact with the soil, with no air gaps.
- Overlap edges and bury the top edge in a small trench.
- Secure with stakes or staples, following the product’s spacing instructions.
- For plantings, cut a small X or hole at each plant.
Full planting steps are in how to plant ground cover on a steep slope.
Wildlife and netting
Some plastic or tightly woven netting can trap snakes, amphibians and other wildlife. Look for loose-woven natural-fibre netting, such as jute or coir, if you can. Also check how long the blanket takes to break down, since long-lasting products can get in the way of growing plants.