The short answer
Both are classic shade plants, and they combine well. In general:
- Choose hostas for big, bold, colourful leaves in moist soil, if you can manage slugs and snails.
- Choose ferns for fine, feathery texture, and for evergreen or semi-evergreen foliage. They often cope better with dry shade, depending on the species.
Neither is a true carpeting ground cover like ivy or vinca. Both form clumps, which will knit together to cover soil if planted close, but they take longer to do so.
Side-by-side
| Hostas | Ferns | |
|---|---|---|
| Foliage | Large, broad, in green, blue, gold or variegated | Finely divided or strap-shaped fronds |
| Winter | Die back completely | Many are evergreen or semi-evergreen |
| Flowers | Lavender or white spikes in summer | None (ferns reproduce by spores) |
| Slugs and snails | A major target | Generally less troubled, though young fronds may be nibbled |
| Moisture | Prefer moist, fertile soil | Varies: some like damp, others tolerate drier shade |
| Light | Partial to dappled shade; some tolerate more | Shade-loving, from light to deep shade |
| Spread | Slowly expanding clumps | Clumping or creeping depending on species |
Hostas: pros and cons
Pros: striking leaf size and colour, reliable return each year, and summer flowers that bees visit. Many cultivars exist.
Cons: slugs and snails can reduce leaves to lace in a wet spring. They are bare in winter. Blue-leaved types may scorch or fade in too much sun, while very deep shade can reduce vigour. In some regions, deer eat hostas readily, as covered in our piece on deer-resistant ground cover for shade gardens.
Slug control options include removing hiding places, watering in the morning, using wildlife-friendly deterrents or barriers, and choosing thicker-leaved, blue-green cultivars, which are often said to be less appealing to slugs.
Ferns: pros and cons
Pros: attractive in unfurling spring growth, textural contrast with broader leaves, and several hardy types hold their leaves through winter. Some are very tough.
Cons: many need consistent moisture, and fronds can brown in dry spells. Some species spread freely.
Examples worth knowing (more in good ground cover ferns):
- Hart’s tongue fern (Asplenium scolopendrium): evergreen, with glossy strap-shaped fronds. It likes damp shade.
- Soft shield fern (Polystichum setiferum): a graceful semi-evergreen to evergreen fern.
- Male fern (Dryopteris filix-mas): reliable and tolerant of some dryness.
- Japanese painted fern (Athyrium niponicum var. pictum): silvery foliage that lights up shade.
Which for which situation?
- Moist shade with decent soil: hostas, or ferns, or both.
- Dry shade under trees: ferns such as male fern are better bets than hostas, but neither is ideal in really dry conditions. See ground cover for dry shade.
- Year-round cover: ferns win, or use evergreen ground covers. See evergreen ground cover for shade.
- Slug-prone gardens: ferns are the safer choice.
- Colour and flowers: hostas, plus companions such as those in flowering ground cover for shade.
Use both together
Mix them: ferns beside hostas gives a contrast between fine and broad foliage. Fill gaps with a true carpeter such as vinca, epimedium or sweet woodruff. For general planting guidance, see our overview of ground cover for shade.