What makes the ground under pines difficult?
Pines are tough to garden beneath for several reasons, and not all of them are about needles.
- Dry soil. The canopy sheds a lot of rain, and the roots take up what reaches the ground.
- Shade. Dense, mature pines cast heavy shade, although the shade is often lighter under open, high-canopied trees such as Scots pine.
- Root competition. Roots are often close to the surface.
- Soil type. Pines often grow on poor, sandy and acidic soils, so the soil is acidic because of what is there, not only because of the needles.
- Needle litter. A thick layer of needles forms a slow-rotting mat that can stop seeds germinating and small plants establishing.
A popular belief is that pine needles make soil very acidic. In practice, the effect of needles on soil acidity is generally modest. Fresh needles are acidic, but the amount that actually changes the soil is usually small compared with the soil’s existing chemistry. If you are concerned, a simple pH test kit will tell you more than guessing.
Plants that tolerate pine conditions
Choose plants that tolerate dry, acidic or neutral soil and light-to-moderate shade. Results vary, so start small and see how plants respond.
- Lesser periwinkle (Vinca minor): evergreen and tolerant, but it can spread.
- Barrenwort (Epimedium): dry-shade tolerant once established.
- Cranesbill (Geranium macrorrhizum): copes with dry soil and partial shade.
- Hardy cyclamen (Cyclamen hederifolium): flowers in autumn and often does well in dry soil under conifers.
- Heathers (Erica, Calluna): acid-loving and suited to light shade, especially under open pines. Flowering is best with some sun.
- Wintergreen (Gaultheria procumbens): a low evergreen that likes acidic soil.
- Lingonberry and cowberry (Vaccinium vitis-idaea): low evergreen shrubs that prefer acidic soil.
- Bearberry (Arctostaphylos uva-ursi): an acid-loving evergreen that suits dry, sandy soil with some light. Known as kinnikinnick, it is among the native groundcovers of BC.
- Creeping mahonia (Mahonia repens): a low, tolerant evergreen shrub.
- Lilyturf, woodrush and ferns: evergreen foliage for dry shade. Check that ferns have enough moisture.
Compare options in ground cover for dry shade and evergreen ground cover for shade.
Planting under pines
- Rake back the needles from the planting spot. They can be returned as a thin mulch afterwards.
- Dig carefully. Pines have important surface roots, so work with a hand trowel and avoid cutting large roots. See how to plant ground cover under a tree.
- Improve the planting hole lightly with compost or leaf mould. Do not pile soil deeply on roots.
- Water well until plants are established, which may take a couple of seasons.
- Mulch thinly, and keep it away from the trunk. Pine needles themselves make a decent, free mulch for acid-loving plants; see ground cover vs mulch.
What about grass?
Grass under pines is often thin because of dryness, root competition and shade. For a closer look, read grass in deep shade and under trees. For broader advice, see our main guide to ground cover for shade.