Why people replace their lawn
Lawns need regular mowing, and in many climates they also need watering and feeding to stay green. Ground covers can reduce some of that work, offer flowers for pollinators, and cover spots where grass struggles, such as dry shade or slopes. They are not maintenance-free, though, and none of them behaves exactly like turf.
The honest trade-off is this: most ground covers tolerate light to moderate foot traffic at best. If your lawn is a play area or a dog run, read the notes on walkable ground cover and dog-friendly options before deciding to replace all of it.
Start with the site, not the plant
Four things narrow your choices quickly:
- Light. Full sun, part shade and deep shade favour different plants. Thyme and sedum want sun. Sweet woodruff, wild ginger and foamflower prefer shade.
- Soil and drainage. Many low herbs dislike wet soil (see ground cover for problem soils). Moss and some shade plants tolerate or prefer damp, acidic ground.
- Traffic. Decide whether the area is walked on daily, occasionally or never.
- Climate. Check the hardiness of any plant against your winter lows, and think about whether summer drought is a concern.
Ground cover options by situation
| Situation | Plants often used |
|---|---|
| Light foot traffic, full sun | Creeping thyme, white clover, Roman chamomile, brass buttons |
| Dry or poor soil, sun | Sedum, creeping thyme, bearberry |
| Shade | Sweet woodruff, wild ginger, foamflower, moss |
| Between stones | Small creepers, see plants between pavers |
| Pollinator-friendly lawn | Clover, self-heal, lawn daisy, see bee lawns and wildflower turf |
For specific plants, see clover, creeping thyme and moss.
Ground covers for Ontario and other cold climates
In cold-winter regions, plant choice starts with hardiness. Native or well-adapted plants commonly suggested for Ontario and similar climates, such as the northeastern United States, include:
- Bearberry (Arctostaphylos uva-ursi) for sunny, sandy, well-drained spots.
- Wild ginger (Asarum canadense) for shade.
- Foamflower (Tiarella cordifolia) for woodland-style shade.
- Wild strawberry (Fragaria virginiana) for sun to part shade, with small fruit.
- Pennsylvania sedge (Carex pensylvanica), a fine-textured sedge sometimes used as a mowed or unmowed lawn substitute in shade.
- White clover, which is naturalised rather than native but widely used.
Roadside and driveway edges may get winter road salt, so test a small area first; see salt-tolerant ground cover for roadsides and driveways. Spring and early fall are generally good planting windows because roots establish before summer heat or winter freeze. Confirm hardiness zones with a local nursery, since microclimates vary.
Choosing something that is not invasive
Some popular creepers spread aggressively and can escape into natural areas. Creeping Jenny (Lysimachia nummularia), periwinkle and English ivy are listed as invasive or problematic in parts of North America. Check your regional invasive species list before buying (see invasive ground covers to avoid), and favour native or clearly non-aggressive plants where you can.
How to replace a lawn, step by step
- Remove or kill the grass. Options include smothering, solarizing or cutting the sod. See how to kill grass without chemicals.
- Prepare the soil. Loosen compacted soil and remove roots. Add compost only if your chosen plant benefits from it.
- Plant plugs or small pots at the spacing on the plant label (see ground cover plant spacing), then water well.
- Mulch gaps lightly and weed regularly while the plants fill in.
- Water consistently through the first season.
Budget matters too. Plugs and seed cost less than mature plants, and cost depends heavily on area and plant choice. See the cost of replacing a lawn with ground cover.
What to expect: establishment and upkeep
Expect the first one to two growing seasons to need attention. Weeds will compete until the plants knit together, and some areas may need replanting. After that, upkeep is usually lighter than a lawn, but not zero: occasional weeding, trimming back edges and watering in dry spells.
Check local rules before you start
Many municipalities have by-laws about grass or weed height and about front-yard appearance, and some homeowner associations restrict lawn removal. Intentionally planted gardens are often treated differently from neglected lawns, but wording varies. Check with your municipality or association first, especially for a front yard. For ideas on that space, see front garden ideas without a lawn.
Where to go next
If you are replacing only part of your lawn, start with the problem spot and expand once you see how the plants perform. A small trial patch costs little and shows you how your soil, light and local conditions behave.