What compacted soil is and how to spot it
Compaction happens when soil particles are pressed together, squeezing out the air and water spaces that roots need. Common causes are heavy machinery or building work, vehicles, constant foot traffic and working clay soil when it is wet. Signs include:
- water that runs off or pools on the surface instead of soaking in
- a garden fork or spade that is hard to push in
- shallow, stunted roots and thin, patchy growth
- a hard crust on top and a dense layer below
Clay soils compact more easily than sandy ones, and compacted clay can be very difficult to plant into.
Loosen first, if you can
Even the toughest plants do better if their roots can get in. The most useful steps are:
- Wait for the right moisture. Soil that is moist but not wet is easiest to work. Dry compacted soil is like concrete, and wet clay smears and compacts further.
- Break up the surface. For small areas, use a garden fork, pushing it in and rocking it back and forth without turning the soil over. For large areas, hire a tool or contractor, such as a core aerator or subsoiler.
- Add organic matter. Spread compost or leaf mould over the surface and lightly work it in. See preparing clay soil for ground cover for what helps and what does not.
- Mulch afterwards to protect the surface from rain, which can reseal it.
If a site was heavily compacted by construction, there may be a very hard layer below. A professional landscaper or arborist can advise, especially if trees are involved; see how to plant ground cover under a tree.
Tough ground cover choices
Plants that are often recommended for hard, tight soil include:
- White clover (Trifolium repens), which is tough, tolerates traffic and compaction, and adds nitrogen to soil. See clover lawn pros and cons.
- Bugle (Ajuga reptans), which tolerates heavy soil in sun or shade.
- Bigroot geranium (Geranium macrorrhizum) for dry shade and difficult soil.
- Spotted dead nettle (Lamium maculatum).
- Lesser periwinkle (Vinca minor), tough but invasive in some regions.
- Creeping Jenny (Lysimachia nummularia) on soil that stays moist.
- Creeping thyme (Thymus serpyllum), which tolerates light foot traffic in sunny spots.
- Sedges (Carex), whose fibrous roots cope with many soils.
- Pachysandra and Epimedium in shade, where soil is not too dry.
Keep in mind that tolerance for compaction is relative. Few plants thrive in truly hard-packed ground; they simply manage better than most. For a clay soil with shade, see what plants thrive in heavy clay soil and shade.
Using roots and cover crops to open soil
Some plants with strong taproots or dense root systems help break up compacted soil over time. Gardeners sometimes sow cover crops such as radishes (including tillage radish), clover, rye or mustard on bare compacted ground, then cut them down and leave the residue. This improves soil gradually. It is a slower approach and works best alongside loosening and organic matter, rather than replacing them.
Planting method
- Use small plants or plugs. They establish more easily in tight soil than large pot-bound plants.
- Dig wide, not deep, holes, and loosen the soil around each hole. A narrow, deep hole in compacted clay can act like a flowerpot that fills with water.
- Plant at the same depth as in the pot.
- Water well, then regularly through the first season.
- Spread a thin layer of mulch, but keep it off the stems.
Preventing re-compaction
- Keep vehicles and heavy equipment off planted areas.
- Put in stepping stones or a path where people walk regularly, with low plants between the pavers if you like.
- Avoid digging or walking on the soil when it is wet.
- Keep the soil covered with plants or mulch.
- Add organic matter each year.
For a mud-prone lawn, see muddy backyard fixes, and for the full range of problem soils, see ground cover for problem soils.